There's something special about a morning spent over a fresh bagel, a perfectly brewed cup, and the kind of warmth that makes you want to stay a while longer. That's exactly what we've been doing right here on Carleton Avenue.
Bagel Brunch Cafe started with a simple belief: that the best meals begin with the best ingredients, and the best experiences begin with genuine hospitality. Located on Carleton Avenue, we've become a quiet staple in East Islip — the kind of place where regulars arrive before 8 a.m. and strangers leave feeling like they've found something rare.
Every bagel is baked with care, every coffee is pulled with intention, and every plate is assembled the way it should be — with pride, and without shortcuts.
Every item on our menu is crafted with the same attention to detail — because breakfast and brunch deserve nothing less.
From classic sesame to our signature Everything, each bagel is hand-shaped, boiled, and baked fresh every morning. Pair it with house-made cream cheese — plain, scallion, or smoked salmon.
Our weekend brunch is the reason people set their alarms. Fluffy omelets, benedicts with a twist, avocado toast that actually lives up to the name — every plate is built to satisfy.
Single-origin espresso, perfectly pulled every time. Whether you prefer a cortado, a matcha latte, or a classic drip, our baristas take their craft seriously.
Everything we do is designed around one idea: that the best part of your day starts here.
Warm lighting, comfortable seating, and the gentle hum of conversation — our space is designed for lingering, whether you're catching up with a friend or enjoying a quiet moment alone.
We source locally, bake daily, and never cut corners. From the flour in our bagels to the beans in your espresso, every ingredient earns its place on your plate.
We're not a chain. We're your neighbors. Many of our team have been here for years, and we take real pride in knowing our regulars by name.
This is hands-down the best brunch spot in the area. The bagels are unmatched, and the coffee is always perfect. We come here every weekend — it's become our family tradition.
I brought out-of-town friends here and they couldn't stop talking about it. The atmosphere is warm, the food is incredible, and the staff makes you feel completely at home.
Everything is fresh, everything is made with care, and everything just tastes better here. It's rare to find a place that gets it right this consistently. I recommend it to everyone.
We're located in the heart of East Islip, easy to find and always happy to welcome you.
217 Carleton Ave
East Islip, NY 11730-1603
Free parking available on-site
